Children sold into domestic servitude through the restavèk system in Haiti

In 1804, Haiti did what no enslaved people had ever done. It won. The Armée Indigène defeated Napoleon's forces and founded a republic on a principle radical enough to terrify every colonial power watching: ‘Tout moun se moun’, all people are human, no one above another. Professor Walner Osna, a visiting scholar at the University of Columbia British, calls it one of the most philosophically profound acts of decolonisation in modern history. The revolution didn't just end slavery. It declared, constitutionally, that such a thing could never happen again.

Haiti currently has an estimated 200,000 child slaves.10% of all children aged 5-17.

They are called restavèk, from the French rester avec, to stay with, and there is a bitter irony in that name. These children do not just stay. They are sent, predominantly from rural families crushed by poverty, to urban households where they will work 16 to 20 hour days fetching water, cleaning, washing clothes, and raising other people's children. They receive no pay. They often attend no school. Many sleep on the floor.

The system once carried a different logic; wealthier families historically took in children, educated them, treated them as their own. That version still exists, occasionally. What replaced it, at scale, is a system blatantly characterised by exploitation. Even poor Haitian families now take in restavèk children.

The consequences inscribe themselves on the body. Restavèk children are on average 4 centimetres shorter than their peers, malnourishment measured not in surveys but in stunted growth. For girls, who represent two-thirds of all restavèk children, the danger is compounded at every turn: approximately 5% of female restavèk children are sexually assaulted each year, roughly 7,000 girls, in a system that has been meticulously documented by civil society organisations and met with near-total indifference by the Haitian state. 85% of children aged 1 to 14 across Haiti have experienced psychological or corporal punishment. For a restavèk child; no parents present, no legal identity, no one who will ask questions, there is no floor beneath which treatment cannot fall.

To understand how a nation founded on the abolition of slavery came to house 200,000 child labourers, you have to go back 21 years after independence, to one of the most audacious acts of economic extortion in recorded history.

In 1825, France, the country Haiti had defeated, the country that had enslaved its people, sent warships to Port-au-Prince and presented a bill. 150 million francs. What a  New York Times investigation calculated as the modern equivalent of $560 million, and what economists believe, had it remained in Haiti, could have compounded into more than $20 billion of domestic investment, for the recognition of a freedom Haiti had already bled to win. Haiti, isolated and economically strangled by the same colonial powers threatened by its existence, agreed. It spent the next century and a half repaying it, borrowing from French and American banks to service a debt it owed for the privilege of being free. The last payment was made in 1947. The economic infrastructure that debt prevented from being built; schools, hospitals, roads and agricultural investment, was never built. As Professor Osna argues, contemporary Haitian poverty is not background context. It is the intended result of a financial architecture designed by colonial powers to ensure that the revolution's promise remained permanently unaffordable.

Today, over half of Haiti's population lives below the $1-a-day poverty line. 76% live on less than $2. The rural interior, what Professor Osna, drawing on Frantz Fanon, calls the ‘zone of non-being’, has been stripped of land, starved of public goods, and left to generate one export the urban economy reliably absorbs: its children.

The 2010 earthquake; 7.0 magnitude, striking less than 20 miles from Port-au-Prince and displacing over 1.26 million people, did not create the restavèk system. It simply demonstrated how little protection surrounded it. Since the disaster, nearly 8,000 children have been trafficked across the border into the Dominican Republic. More than 25,800 children sit in institutional care, 80% of whom are not orphans. 1 in 6 Haitian children is not registered at birth; no legal identity, no access to social services, no record of their existence should they disappear. Nearly 80% of children held in Haitian prisons have never been charged with anything.

Into this catastrophe arrived, as it always does, the international humanitarian apparatus. Professor Osna is precise about what it has and has not done. Drawing on the work of Haitian sociologist Jean Anil Louis-Juste, he argues that NGOs in Haiti function less as agents of change than as mechanisms of colonial governance. Systems that manage populations without threatening the structures that produce their suffering. The persistence of the problem, he notes, is also the persistence of the institution. An NGO that solved the restavèk crisis would have no further reason to exist, no further projects to fund, no further expertise to export. The incentive structure is not accidental.

The legal framework exists. ILO Conventions 138, 182, and 189 cover child domestic labour in exhaustive detail. They are largely irrelevant to a girl in Port-au-Prince who cannot read them, cannot report a violation, and belongs, often in the eyes of the household keeping her, to a category of person the law has never quite reached.

Tout moun se moun. All people are human.

Somewhere in the distance between that founding declaration and its 200,000 daily violations, Professor Osna locates the question that two centuries of child protection research has failed to ask: not how to manage the restavèk system, but how to dismantle the colonial order that makes it, generation after generation, entirely logical.

The revolution happened. Its children are still waiting to be included in it.

Further information and opportunities to engage with organisations working in this area are listed below:
Restavek Freedom
Haiti - Forward Edge
HAITI-Education program for Restavek children

Share This Article

What's Your Opinion?

Share your thoughts on this article